5 Best Resorts in Key West
When it comes to finding the perfect place to stay in Key West, the options can be overwhelming. To help you narrow it down, I’ve compiled a list of five of the best hotels in the area. These top picks were chosen based on their prime locations near popular attractions, excellent amenities, high guest ratings, and unique features that capture the charm and beauty of Key West. Whether you're looking for a luxurious resort, a historic gem, or a stylish retreat, these hotels offer a range of experiences that will make your stay unforgettable.
Alinea
1/12/20253 min read
Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the links in this post may be affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. Your support helps keep this blog running—thank you!
You can easily book both your car rental and flight through Expedia, and while you're at it, be sure to sign up for their OneKey Rewards program. You’ll enjoy discounts, exclusive deals, and earn points right off the bat. It's too great of an offer not to share, especially if you're planning to book your flight, stay, and car rental all through Expedia!
And with that, let's dive in!
The Pier House Resort & Spa
This iconic Key West hotel offers a private beach, lush gardens, a pool, and a renowned spa. With its prime location on the waterfront and close proximity to Duval Street, The Pier House provides the perfect balance of relaxation and excitement.
The Opal Key Resort & Marina
Located in the heart of Key West, this upscale resort offers spacious rooms, a heated outdoor pool, a marina, a roof top bar, and stunning waterfront views. It’s a great choice for those looking to explore Old Town Key West and enjoy easy access to dining, shopping, and entertainment.
The Southernmost House Hotel
Known for its stunning location at the southernmost point of the U.S., this historic hotel combines luxury with a sense of Old Key West charm. With beautiful oceanfront views, an infinity pool, and elegant rooms, it’s perfect for couples looking for a romantic retreat.
Santa Maria Suites
Santa Maria Suites is a fantastic choice for a stay in Key West. The spacious suites come with a full kitchen, comfortable living areas, and private patios, making it feel like a home away from home. The pool area is a peaceful retreat, surrounded by lush landscaping. Located just a short walk from Duval Street, you’re close to all the best attractions while still enjoying a quiet, relaxing environment. With great service and excellent amenities, Santa Maria Suites offers a top-notch experience in Key West.
The Mansion
on the Sea
The Mansion by the Sea Resort is a stunning escape in Key West, blending luxury with artistic beauty. The spacious rooms feature modern amenities and are designed with vibrant, locally inspired decor. The private beach offers breathtaking ocean views, while the pool area provides a peaceful retreat. With top-notch service and easy access to local attractions, this resort offers a perfect mix of relaxation and creative charm. It’s an ideal spot for those seeking both tranquility and artistic inspiration.
Conclusion
From private beaches and artistic suites to breathtaking views and rooftop bars, these top-notch resorts offer a variety of experiences to choose from. If you're looking for fun activities in Key West, be sure to check out my Ultimate Key West Couples Guide Blog. You can also explore my Key West Getaways Board on Pinterest for more Key West-focused pins that will help you plan a seamless and memorable trip. Finally, if you're still debating between booking a hotel or a Vrbo check out my 5 Vrbo's with Private Pools Blog for more variety!
Conclusion
Key West offers a diverse range of Vrbo homes with private pools, each providing a unique blend of style, comfort, and prime location. Whether you're seeking a peaceful retreat surrounded by tropical beauty or a luxurious base close to Key West's top attractions, these homes deliver an unforgettable experience. From cozy cottages to sprawling estates, these properties provide the perfect balance of relaxation and adventure to immerse yourself in the charm of Key West.
If you're looking for fun activities in Key West, be sure to check out my Ultimate Key West Couples Guide Blog. You can also explore my Key West Getaways Board on Pinterest for more Key West-focused pins that will help you plan a seamless and memorable trip. Finally, if you're still debating on whether or not you should book a hotel or Vrbo, read my Best Resorts in Key West Blog for more variety!
Other Helpful Articles For Your Trip From Fellow Travel Bloggers
The Ultimate Key West Food Guide
- by Jenessa
5 Best Spots to See a Key West Sunset
-by Tam
How to Day Trip to Dry Tortugas
-by Amanda
16 Best Stops From Miami to Florida
-by Victoria & Terrence
All of these blogs can also be easily accessed on my Key West Getaways Board on Pinterest
God Bless
-Alinea
© 2025. All rights reserved.
Do not sell my information.
About Me: Hi! I’m Alinea, the voice behind Coffee Talk Getaways. I am a Navy Vet that works in Water Operations with my husband who is passionate about travel. Having been well-traveled around the US, I created this blog to share top destinations, travel tips, and insider recommendations to make your trips seamless and memorable. Traveling doesn’t have to be hard. I’m here to make it easier, more exciting, and filled with unforgettable moments. Join me as we explore the world, one getaway at a time!